Yaks, or Mozart?

October 28, 2006

Only rarely do I read the Business pages of the newspapers, but last night I couldn’t go to bed until I’d finished reading a most thought provoking article in yesterday’s Globe and Mail’s Report on Business magazine, which you can find on-line here if you’re interested. It was about the ways in which Bombardier and Nortel are helping China to change Tibet by the opening of a new railway through the extremely wild, high country between Golmud and Llasa, “Nortel’s GSM-R system [allowing] a wide range of technical signalling, voice communication and text messaging on even the most remote stretches of the Tibet railway…” The quality of the engineering—the networks, the infrastructure, the oxygen enriched railway cars designed by Bombardier—is phenomenal, no question, and the train service and consequent influx of Chinese business men is sure to transform that part of the world. What is debatable though, is whether or not the Tibetans will find their lives improved by this transformation.

It is very like the coming of the europeans to western Canada in the 19th century. They changed things. They aimed to “civilise” the west (or make money out of it) and did so most successfully, but at what cost to the native inhabitants? Now a Chinese spokesman is saying about the Tibetans, “In the past, the herdsmen had weak economic thinking… If they were fed and sheltered, they were satisfied. But […] thanks to technology and development, now they are entering the market economy.”

Is it progress then, not to be satisfied with simple food and shelter any more? Is it better to pay less respect to the animals one must kill for meat, by starting to butcher them wholesale without the dignity of a traditional “crying ceremony” for the sanctity of each life? Is it more civilised for the tourists in Tibet’s capital to “swarm into [the] temples and grab the monks for photos, even in the middle of theological discussions”? The Globe and Mail article raises such questions.

A Nortel spokesman has a more optimistic point of view. He says that the new developments in communication between Tibet and China will “reduce bias and improve tolerance,” which cannot help but be a good thing.

If the tide cannot be stopped, perhaps we should all try to think in this way.

I am thinking of Sydney, Australia, not so long ago a place as wild and remote as Tibet. Tomorrow afternoon at Sydney’s Town Hall hundreds of local school children from the city will be singing in a performance of Mozart’s Requiem. I am proud to add that my son and daughter-in-law will be playing in the accompanying orchestra. Now that is what I call civilised. Mozart, if he’d known about this concert, would have been amazed.

One Response to “Yaks, or Mozart?”


  1. […] Then the lids came off the serving dishes and we lined up for our vegetarian supper (in keeping with the charity’s Gandhian philosophy, as the programme put it), to eat which everyone stood at candlelit tables. We were too many to have chairs. The chance to sit down came afterwards, when we were ushered into the Beaux Arts style, former Departures Hall, now transformed into a sort of theatre nearly 30 metres high. The floor show ranged from deep solemnity to hilarity. We were entertained with Indian dancing, a yoga demonstration and juggling by the compère who performed incredible tricks with five crystal balls. Slide shows of the charity’s homes in India, Bangladesh, Nepal and Tibet were projected and stories of the recipients’ lives read to us. One destitute Tibetan child, helped by the charity, has recently been enrolled as a student at Beijing University, probably travelling there on the railway I mentioned in a previous blog. […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: